Bookkeeper vs Accountant for a Small Business
Understanding the Difference & Making the Right Choice for Your Business
Introduction
Running a small business means wearing many hats—but accounting shouldn't be one of them. Whether you're managing cash flow, preparing for taxes, or trying to understand your profit margins, chances are you've wondered: Do I need a bookkeeper or an accountant?
The answer: maybe both.
But the roles are very different—and knowing the distinction could save you time, stress, and money.
This guide breaks down the key differences between a bookkeeper and an accountant, explains when and why you might need each, and helps you make the best decision for your small business.
The Key Difference: Bookkeeper vs Accountant
| Function | Bookkeeper | Accountant |
|---|---|---|
| Main Focus | Daily financial records & reconciliation | Strategic financial advice & tax planning |
| Tasks | Transaction recording, bank recs, invoices | Financial analysis, tax filing, audit support |
| Tools Used | QuickBooks, Xero, Wave | Same, plus tax software (e.g., UltraTax) |
| Credentials | Not always certified | Often a CPA or EA |
| Timeline | Ongoing (daily/weekly/monthly) | Periodic (quarterly, annually) |
In short: A bookkeeper keeps your financial house in order. An accountant makes sure it's built on a strong foundation.
What Does a Bookkeeper Do?
Bookkeepers are the backbone of day-to-day financial management.
✅ Typical Responsibilities:
- Record income and expenses
- Categorize transactions correctly
- Reconcile bank and credit card accounts
- Manage accounts receivable and payable
- Prepare monthly financial reports
- Maintain clean records for tax season
They work closely with your accountant to ensure everything is accurate and organized.
What Does an Accountant Do?
Accountants take your financial data and use it to offer strategic insights and ensure tax compliance.
✅ Typical Responsibilities:
- Analyze financial reports
- Provide budgeting and forecasting support
- File business taxes
- Offer financial and tax planning
- Ensure compliance with IRS regulations
- Help with entity setup and structure
CPAs (Certified Public Accountants) are licensed and can represent you in front of the IRS, while EAs (Enrolled Agents) specialize in taxes and can do the same.
Do I Need a Bookkeeper or an Accountant?
When You Need a Bookkeeper:
- You want accurate, up-to-date records
- You don't have time to track every transaction
- You're behind on reconciling your bank accounts
- You need monthly financial reports to guide decisions
When You Need an Accountant:
- It's tax season or you need year-end filings
- You're planning for business growth, funding, or expansion
- You need help choosing your business structure
- You're making large financial decisions
When You Need Both:
- You're generating consistent revenue
- You want to minimize taxes and maximize growth
- You need a clean handoff from monthly bookkeeping to tax filing
Real-World Example: How They Work Together
Let's say you run a Shopify store:
- Your bookkeeper categorizes sales, refunds, expenses, and tracks your inventory monthly using Xero or QuickBooks.
- Your accountant uses the year-end reports to file taxes, offer advice on deductions, and help you decide whether to become an S-Corp.
It's a tag-team effort: the bookkeeper keeps the data clean; the accountant makes sense of it.
Common Misconceptions
"My accountant can do my bookkeeping."
Technically, yes—but it's a costly use of their time (and your money). Most CPAs prefer receiving clean books, not doing the cleanup.
"A bookkeeper can do my taxes."
Unless they're a licensed CPA or EA, they shouldn't. However, they prepare everything your tax professional needs.
"I only need one."
If you're serious about growth, it's like having a trainer and a nutritionist. Each has a specific role that complements the other.
How to Choose the Right Help
🔍 Bookkeeper Checklist:
- Familiar with your industry
- Certified in QuickBooks/Xero
- Offers regular reporting (monthly at minimum)
- Available for questions
- Experience with your business size
🔍 Accountant Checklist:
- CPA or EA credentials
- Experience with small business tax
- Understands your industry
- Responsive and proactive
- Provides strategic insights, not just tax prep
FAQ: Bookkeeper vs. Accountant
Q: Can I hire one person to do both?
A: Sometimes, yes—but be cautious. Most "full-service" providers still split roles behind the scenes. Make sure they're licensed to do taxes if that's part of your agreement.
Q: How do I know if my business is ready for both?
A: If your monthly income is over $10K, or if you have employees or investors, you'll likely benefit from both services.
Q: What's the cost difference?
A: Bookkeepers usually cost $199–$699/mo depending on complexity. Accountants or CPAs charge $150–$500/hr or a flat fee for taxes. Hiring both strategically can still save you money.
Pro Tip: Look for Bookkeepers with CPA Oversight
At FinanceGuard, all bookkeeping services are reviewed by licensed CPAs. That means you get:
- Real-time, accurate financials
- Clean handoff to your accountant
- Expert advice when you need it
- Peace of mind year-round
Final Thoughts
You don't have to choose between a bookkeeper and an accountant—they both play critical roles in your business. The key is understanding when to bring them in and how they work together.
Still not sure what you need? Book a free consultation and we'll walk you through it.
Internal Links:
External Links:
Related Articles
How to Choose a Bookkeeper for Your Small Business
April 4, 2025
Discover how to choose the right bookkeeper for your small business. Learn what to look for, red fla...
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.